In Memoriam: John Lennon

It’s hard to come to grips with the fact that it’s been 35 years since we lost John Lennon. Here’s a piece I wrote that originally was published in Beatlefan #13, December 1980, the special Commemorative Issue published two weeks after Lennon’s death. 

john white album

I lost a very dear friend Monday night, Dec. 8, 1980 — one that I had never met.

That, I’m sure, is how millions of other Beatles fans felt when they heard the news that a senseless act of violence had taken the life of one of the greatest influences on our generation.

John Lennon.

Dead at age 40.

DEAD?

Give teeth a chance: John Lennon.Even now, after all the headlines and television retrospectives and magazine covers and photos of his grief-stricken widow, I can’t quite bring myself to accept that one of the Fab Foursome of John/Paul/George/Ringo — we tended to run it all together like one name, almost a mantra to some — has been silenced forever.

Some people don’t quite comprehend just what that means to those of us who grew up with The Beatles and who are hurting so badly right now. They don’t understand the bond between performers and audience that developed over the nearly 17 years since Lennon and cohorts Paul McCartney, George Harrison and Ringo Starr left the obscurity of Liverpool for the international limelight.

Most of them do at least recognize that the world of popular music has lost a giant. That distinctive, slightly nasal voice of “A Hard Day’s Night”, “All You Need Is Love” and “Imagine” — considered by many to be just about the perfect rock ‘n’ roll instrument — exists now only in our memories and in the several hundred million records it is estimated The Beatles have sold worldwide.

john flowerThe brilliant, eccentric wordmaster who made up half of the most successful songwriting team in the annals of popular music — and who, for many of us, defined the turbulent but exciting 1960s with his incisive, witty and oft-times painful lyrics — will write no more.

The Beatles revolutionized music. But, quite obviously, they were more than just a musical group. For better or worse, they were in the vanguard (often as instigators) of many cultural upheavals with their long hair, colorful dress, working class origins and outspoken views on drugs, sex and politics.

Lennon, of course, was always the most vocal. He was the one who observed (quite rightly, it could be argued) that The Beatles were more popular than Jesus Christ among the youth of the mid-’60s.

He occasionally spoke too hastily and later repented, and his words were not always full of wisdom. But no one ever doubted his sincerity. John Lennon cared.

We knew that. And even if we didn’t agree with what he said or the way he said it (and, contrary to popular belief, we didn’t all follow him blindly in his ventures into mysticism, drug-induced consciousness alteration and shrill radicalism), we were somehow comforted and at the same time stimulated by the knowledge that our friend was out there searching for some sort of better world.

Lennon And OnoIt is the bitterest of ironies that Lennon, a childhood ruffian who grew up to be one of the world’s most ardent pacifists and a vocal opponent of the Vietnam War, died at the hand of a gunman.

But, then, the story of John Lennon’s death is rife with irony. He fought long and hard to stay in this country when threatened with deportation because he loved the city where he was to be gunned down.

He felt that in New York City he could walk down the streets unmolested as just another citizen. He couldn’t really, of course.

A friend of mine ended up sitting at a table next to the Lennons at Nani’s Italian restaurant a week or so before his death. A slightly intoxicated patron went up to Lennon, who was quietly sipping cappucino, and demanded to know, “How are The Beatles?” Lennon simply said, “I don’t know.” Not satisfied, the man got drunker and returned to Lennon’s table a little later to pester him some more. Wearily, John looked up at him and said, “Why don’t you just leave me alone?”

john and seanJohn Lennon was still a prisoner of fame, despite his five years away from the spotlight. As Robert Christgau (with whom I rarely agree) observed so cynically, “He died because he was famous.” Or, more pointedly, because the little nobodies of the world like his killer fantasize about the famous. I wonder who is fantasizing about Lennon’s killer right now?

And then there is the sad irony characterized by the title of Lennon’s hit single “(Just Like) Starting Over”. After a five-year self-imposed absence from the music scene, Lennon had just returned to the Top 10 with a song that represented his optimistic state of mind at the time of his death.

As he told Playboy magazine, “life begins at 40 — so they promise. And I believe it, too. I feel fine and I’m very excited. It’s like, you know, hitting 21, like, ‘Wow, what’s going to happen next?'”

He’ll never know.

consti LennonBut those of us he left behind know that the legend and legacy of John Lennon is considerable. He was a lot more than just another rock star. He was a symbol, proof that you could be an innovator and an original and strive for excellence in an age weighted down with mediocrity. And that you could do all that and still make it to the top.

He also showed us that we do not have to become slaves to the expectations others have of us. While still at the top, he walked away from it all to spend time raising the son who shared his birthday. It won’t be easy for little Sean to grow up now that Daddy’s gone, but the foundation built by those five years of intense closeness with his father will no doubt help see him through.

John Lennon wasn’t afraid. He wasn’t afraid of life, of death, of exploring the unknown, of learning. He was willing to admit, as he did shortly before his death, that he had been wrong in some of the things he had said during his radical stage in the early ’70s.

And, once he learned that those joys of family life he had ridiculed Paul McCartney for exulting were really what it’s all about, he set out with a renewed zeal to spread the word.
While many of us welcomed the new upbeat, melodic message Lennon delivered on “Double Fantasy”, others were disappointed to find the former angry young man singing about fatherhood, marriage and family love.

What they failed to see was that this was a mature Lennon singing to us this time around. In Playboy, he dismissed worship of rock stars who burn out at an early age as “garbage.”
“It’s better to fade away like an old soldier than to burn out. I don’t appreciate worship of dead Sid Vicious or of dead James Dean or of dead John Wayne . . . I worship the people who survive.”

john peace signJohn Lennon didn’t waste time looking back. And, in an age where you can hardly avoid hearing a Beatles song on elevator Muzak, he had little patience with those who would insist he and the other ex-Beatles return to the scene of their past glories.

“Everyone talks in terms of the last record or the last Beatle concert,” he told Playboy, “but, God willing, there are another 40 years of productivity to go.”

For whatever reason, God was not willing. And so it is that John Lennon lives now only in his music.

To the end, he was amazingly astute, even when he didn’t know it. In the new song “Beautiful Boy”, written to son Sean, he sang, “Life is what happens to you/ While you’re busy making other plans.”

I feel like crying.

— Bill King

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 5 Comments

REVIEW: John Lennon 75th Birthday Concert

IMAGINE:  JOHN LENNON 75th BIRTHDAY CONCERT, 

THE THEATER AT MADISON SQUARE GARDEN, NEW YORK CITY, DECEMBER 5, 2015

imagine logo

As this 75th birthday year had pretty much come and gone without any fanfare from the Lennon camp, it was nice to have a celebration in the city John Lennon chose to call home as the calendar was winding down.

Presented by the Blackbird Music Group in alliance with the AMC Network, the event raised funds for the Robin Hood Foundation, whose events held at the Garden have included the Concert For New York and the 121212 Hurricane Sandy benefits, both headlined by Lennon’s fellow Beatle, Sir Paul McCartney. But neither Sir Paul nor Ringo Starr would be on hand to celebrate in song on this evening, though both sent videotaped messages which were aired at the event, and will presumably be included in the AMC telecast slated for Dec. 19th.

ticketHosted by MC Kevin Bacon, the line-up of performers was indeed a varied one, and drew on a fairly balanced mix of Lennon’s Beatles and solo repertoires. In addition to several groups on the card, a rotating list of performers were supported by a house band that featured drummer Kenny Aronoff, bassist Lee Sklar, guitarists Sid McGuiness and Felicia Collins (both formerly of the David Letterman “Late Show” CBS Orchestra) and the evening’s musical director, Greg Phillinganes, on keyboards.

While the pace of the evening was hampered by certain re-takes (mostly for Bacon) and downtime needed to ensure a polished final product, the musical performances were generally quite good, and in several cases, exceptional. Here’s a rundown of the set list:

Leading off the proceedings was John Fogerty, who was added to the bill just a couple of days prior. He launched into a ¾ complete version of “Give Peace A Chance”, sticking to the original lyrics and arrangement. An interesting choice, this one is typically held in reserve for an ensemble closing number and given the current climate, might have lent itself to some updated ad-libbed lyrics. Still, having some star power to launch the proceedings served the evening well. Fogerty followed up the opening number with a touching “In My Life”.

Next up was Peter Frampton, who did a straightforward 12-string take on “Norwegian Wood”, a number he’d played during his solo spot while touring with Ringo’s All-Starr Band back in in 1997.

Latin pop star Juanes followed with “Woman”. A good vocal performance, though delivered with nearly zero stage presence.

Aloe Blacc delivered one of the evening’s true highlights, a booming version of “Steel and Glass”, providing the first relatively deep dive into the songbook. Following this rousing performance, he and Phillinganes teamed up for a gospel-tinged piano-only read of “Watching The Wheels”, with an arrangement that recalled Bill Withers’ “Lean on Me”.

Sheryl Crow.

Sheryl Crow.

Donning a New York City T-shirt as made famous in Bob Gruen’s iconic mid-70’s photo of Lennon and armed with a black Rickenbacker 325, Sheryl Crow came on to perform “A Hard Day’s Night”, adeptly handling the alternating Lennon and McCartney lead vocal parts.

A weak-voiced Kris Kristofferson and no-voiced Tom Morello (from Rage Against The Machine) teamed up for one of the evening’s relatively few low points with “Working Class Hero”.

Chris Stapleton, who ran the table at this year’s Country Music Awards, teamed up with Brandon Flowers (of the Killers) and Crow for “Don’t Let Me Down”. The stylistic misalignment was evident, with the soulful feel of the original all but lost in translation. Stapleton fared much better when swapping out cohorts Flowers and Crow for Kristofferson and Willie Nelson on “You’ve Got To Hide Your Love Away”.

Following what seemed like an eternity for re-staging (and not making use of the multiple video screens or even tapping MC Bacon for a little banter), the Roots closed part one of the show with a blistering version of “Mother”, though their self-styled prelude was lost on the majority of those in attendance (maybe they didn’t get the memo that this evening wasn’t about THEM …).

The 5-piece Texas band Spoon opened up the second part of the show with the couplet of “Hey Bulldog” and ”Cold Turkey”, the former being given the “take II” treatment for whatever difficulties (technical, or more likely, the very flat vocal delivery) were incurred. Still, they’re a tight band that went over very well.

john and yokoCuriously, the next slot was by John & Yoko themselves, with a video performance of “Attica State” from their 1971 appearance on the David Frost show. While this would have made for nice filler during intermission or the aforementioned extended restaging, it served as a convenient set-up to introduce Yoko herself, who came out to say a few words, but did not perform.

Back to the proceedings, Nelson came on to do a very moving “Imagine”, garnering a well-deserved standing ovation.

Flowers returned to do a powerful “Instant Karma”. Falling just short of ‘shouting’ the lyrics, his vocal projection filled the room.

Train’s Pat Monahan performed an interesting arrangement of “Jealous Guy”, injecting a reggae flavor to the second half of the song before the band burst into a sped-up piano boogie a-la Elton John’s “Burn Down The Mission”.

While at times struggling with the meter of the lyrics, country star Eric Church did a serviceable “Mind Games”. The band really shined on this one.

An in-your-face version of “Power To The People” followed, featuring the New York Freedom Choir and lead guitar prowess of Morello.

The main set closed with Steven Tyler rocking his way through “Come Together” (which his band Aerosmith had a hit with in the late 70’s) and “Revolution”, being joined on the latter by Church.

The encores opened with video greetings from Ringo, who then introduced a video of his most recent All Starr Band delivering the Lennon-penned “I’m The Greatest” from the superb “Ringo at the Ryman” DVD. That Paul’s video was not played immediately afterward paved the way for some last-minute speculation that he might be …. Naaaaah.

"Happy Xmas (War Is Over)"

“Happy Xmas (War Is Over)”

Back on stage Frampton, Crow and Blacc were joined by a children’s choir for “Happy Xmas (War Is Over)”. Beyond the signature songs such as “Imagine” and “In My Life”, this song remains the one that makes me miss John more than any other every single time I hear it. Meticulously arranged with Frampton on the low verses, Blacc on the high ones, and Crow soaring above the choir in the choruses, the communal singalong – right here during Christmastime in the city (HIS city) made this one an emotional highlight of the evening.

Back to the screens for some comments and a tip of the hat from Sir Paul, though his message was not accompanied by any musical performance. It remains to be seen if one will be added for the broadcast (“Here Today” from the Citifield concert DVD would seem fitting. Just sayin’).

The ensemble finale for this celebration was a fitting “All You Need Is Love” which, while mostly solid and had gotten got everyone up and singing along, was marred by an obviously under-rehearsed cast (when returning to the 3rd verse after the instrumental, no one stepped up until about the last line, when Tyler stepped in). Whether this will be edited or faded under the closing credits is in the hands of the AMC team.

Inclusive of the intermission and production breaks, the show ran just under three hours, so a two-hour broadcast seems likely.

The 5,500 seat theater, which resides on the site of the old Felt Forum, is a great room with low ceilings making for generally superb sound, with excellent sightlines from any seat in the house (in the past, I’ve seen Simon & Garfunkel, James Taylor, Elvis Costello and even The Who there). For the Lennon tribute, it was about 95 percent full, in no small part due to the ticket pricing, which ran from $99 to $1000, with most seats in the $150-$250-$350 range.

Merchandise, which is available from www.blackbirdmusicgroup.com included two different t-shirts, two different event posters, and a hooded sweatshirt.

Yoko Ono

Yoko Ono

While we can all make our dream lists of performers we’d have liked to seen at the event (beyond Paul and Ringo, I mean), and particular favorite songs (the embarrassment of riches in the catalog kept songs like “I Am The Walrus”, “Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds” and “(Just Like) Starting Over” off the table), this was an evening to celebrate what we DO have — and that’s John’s lasting musical and cultural legacy.

“It’s beautiful to see so many wonderful and talented musicians come together for this special show to celebrate John’s birthday,” said Yoko Ono. “John’s art continues to give hope, light and happiness to generations of people everywhere. His belief that each of us can change the world continues to inspire the human race to believe in themselves, and his influence is everlasting in everyone’s hearts as we all share in the possibilities and power of music.”

And so this is Christmas, indeed.

— Tom Frangione

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

The Beatles’ ‘1+’ — A Fan’s Notes

Apple Corps and UMG have announced the Nov. 6 release of multiple configurations of reworked and expanded versions of the “1” album that showcase The Beatles’ promo films along with their 27 No.1 U.K. and U.S. singles. Beatlefan Contributing Editor Tom Frangione offers a fan’s analysis of the impending releases. …

The "1+" deluxe package, due Nov. 6.

The “1+” deluxe package, due Nov. 6.

Back in 1999, when Paul McCartney was at long last inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame as a solo artist, his daughter Stella was at his side wearing a tank-top that none too subtly proclaimed “About F***ing Time.” Such sentiment was never more appropriate, perhaps, than now, with the news that a compilation of Beatles promo films and other video material will be hitting the streets in November. Alongside a newly mixed audio collection of the chart-topping Beatles “1” album, companion videos for each of the 27 songs will be presented.

The "1" album is receiving a completely new stereo remix.

The “1” album is receiving a completely new stereo remix.

Now, The Beatles did not do what we have come to know as promotional videos for all of these songs. Where they didn’t, concert clips, stills and other footage have been compiled to represent the songs. Not having seen the final product, of course, makes it difficult to do much more than speculate, but, by way of example, this approach was used for the 20th anniversary single of “Love Me Do” back in 1982. (It’s unclear whether that version will appear in this release.)

But, for quite a few songs, original promos do exist, dating back to the mid-1960s, when the insatiable demand for live television appearances by The Beatles gave birth to the idea of instead providing programs with performance “promo films” such as for “Ticket to Ride,” which, while not even close to passing as “live” performances (the absence of guitar leads, microphones and amplifiers is more than a minor hint), showed the band miming along while manning their respective instruments.

Yet, even in these relatively early outings, an element of surrealism was creeping in at a robust pace, not unlike the developments heard on another of the band’s side outlets, their annual Christmas records. By 1967, the films were being produced in color and adding even more vivid imagery. For some songs, there were even alternate promos, some of which were not widely seen.

The "1+" CD and DVD standard package.

The “1+” CD and DVD standard package.

Now, at long last, the world at large will get a chance to revel in what video collectors have for years compiled, traded, and upgraded. The samples used in the electronic press kits for the “1+” releases evidence some brilliant remastering.

Collectors will be scrambling to compare the contents to what they have in the latest incarnation of whatever “definitive” bootleg video compilation they have on their shelves (anybody need a copy of “Unsurpassed Promos” or “Chronology” … CHEAP?). Of course, those unsanctioned collections reflected their creators’ whims and often included suitable complementary material, such as the musical “performances” from the various Beatles movies.

A look at the official “1+” track listing shows many of the alternate versions of the promos will be collected on the second DVD (or Blu-ray) to be included in the deluxe editions. So, all three of the well-known versions of “Hello Goodbye” will be in there. In several other cases, a stray alternate does not appear to have made the cut. However, early word is that some of them may be included as “Easter eggs” in the various menus (really? REALLY ? I thought that gimmick went the way of the “hidden bonus track” on CDs). Stay tuned for the results from your favorite sleuths here at Beatlefan.

The "1" CD and Blu-ray configuration.

The “1” CD and Blu-ray configuration.

Speaking of the bonus disc, major kudos to Apple for including the promotional clips for the BBC album tracks “Baby It’s You” and “Words of Love” as well as the new songs presented in the “Anthology” — “Free As a Bird” and “Real Love.”

The release looks to  satisfy a heretofore major gap in The Beatles’ catalog. Obviously, the EMI body of work has been definitively represented by the 2009 remastered series. The runner-up in terms of importance in the story — the BBC recordings — has been substantially covered for all but the most ardent collector. The movies — save for “Let It Be” — have each received the deluxe remastered treatment. And, certainly, the “Anthology” was a noble run through the vaults, though it is now some 20 years in the rear view mirror (can that be?).

Beyond “Let It Be,” the last real vestiges of the canon that remain unissued are the Christmas album, and some of live projects such as the Hollywood Bowl album and Shea Stadium film.

About f***ing time, indeed.

— Tom Frangione

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 4 Comments

Songs That Fans Wish Macca Was Singing

In Beatlefan #214, Bill King asked readers to send in songs they’d love to hear Paul McCartney do in concert that he’s never performed live before as well as songs he’s done in the past that they’d like to see brought back.

He got quite a few responses. Here’s his report on the songs fans would like Macca to add to his set list …

Beatlefan readers speak out on what songs they'd like to see added to McCartney's set list.

Beatlefan readers speak out on what songs they’d like to see added to McCartney’s set list.

This entire exercise was prompted by Paul McCartney adding a couple of unexpected numbers to his spring/summer set list, “Another Girl” and “Temporary Secretary.” The latter being a relatively obscure tune from his “McCartney II” album, it set me to thinking about what other songs he might revive from that decade, which is a favorite of my wife, Leslie.

As it turned out after I polled Beatlefan readers, “Wanderlust,” one of Leslie’s very favorite Macca songs (from that or any period), appears to be a tune that a lot of fans would like to hear in concert.

Tied with “Wanderlust” atop the list of songs that readers would like to see Paul do live was “Take It Away,” another tune from the same album, “Tug of War,” that he only ever did onstage when making the music video in front of fan club members.

Since “Tug of War” is being reissued Oct. 2 as the latest entry in the McCartney Archive series, fall dates on Macca’s Out There! Tour would be the perfect time to add one or both numbers to his set list!

Just behind those two songs in third place on the reader want list was one of the Beatles tunes Macca’s never done in concert, “Oh! Darling,” though a couple of fans expressed reservations that it might take a toll on Paul’s aging voice. Tied for third was another ‘80s tune, “No More Lonely Nights.”

Tied in fourth place were an early solo hit, “Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey,” and one of Macca’s tracks from The Beatles’ White Album, “Rocky Raccoon” (which, as one reader noted, would give him a chance to sing wife Nancy’s name).

And tied for fifth place on the list were a cluster of songs: “Daytime Nightime Suffering” (a personal favorite of mine), “Ballroom Dancing,” “Beautiful Night,” “The World Tonight,” the quirky “Monkberry Moon Delight” and “With a Little Luck.”

Then came another group with slightly less support: “Young Boy,” “No Values,” “Back Seat of My Car,” “Only Love Remains,” “Maxwell’s Silver Hammer,” “Helen Wheels,” “Cafe on the Left Bank” and “Pipes of Peace.”

There are plenty of solo and Beatles songs still to choose from ...

There are plenty of solo and Beatles songs still to choose from …

Other tunes mentioned: “Summer of 59,” “Big Boys Bickering,” “Waterfalls,” “Warm and Beautiful,” “Little Willow,” “Tomorrow,” “Manunia,” “Girls School,” “I’m Carrying,” “I Can Bet,” “Angry,” “Stranglehold,” “Tug of War,” “Spies Like Us,” “Teddy Boy,” “Big Barn Bed,” “Through Our Love,” “Press,” “On the Wings of a Nightingale” (a song Paul wrote for the Everly Brothers), ”Dear Boy,´Oh Woman Oh Why,” “So Glad to See You Here,” “One of These Days,” “Move Over Busker,” “That Day Is Done,” “Get on the Right Thing,” :Heart of the Country,” “Back on My Feet,”  “Friends to Go,” “I’ll Be on My Way” and ”Tell Me What You See.”

Among songs that McCartney has done before in concert that people would like to hear again, the unchallenged leader was “Goodnight Tonight” from Wings’ 1979 U.K. tour.

Tied for second place among would-be returnees were “My Brave Face” (another personal fave of mine), “Getting Closer” and the Beatles tune “She’s a Woman” (done on his 2004 European tour).

What surprises might lurk on the fall Out There! set list?

What surprises might lurk on the fall Out There! set list?

Also drawing some support: “Silly Love Songs” (a highlight of the 1976 Wings Over America tour), “Old Siam Sir” (also from the final Wings tour) and “Figure of Eight,” the ballsy choice of show-opener on Macca’s 1989-90 comeback tour.

Others receiving mention include “Come and Get It” (which was briefly in the set list in 2011 and would be a timely addition this fall with the release of Paul’s Hollywood Vampires rendition of the tune he wrote for Badfinger), “I’ve Had Enough,” “Too Many People/She Came in Through the Bathroom Window” (as done in the 2005 set list that many consider Paul’s finest), “Fool on the Hill,” “For No One,” “Things We Said Today,” “Getting Better,” “Biker Like an Icon,” “Put It There,” “Coming Up,” :Bluebird,” “We Got Married,” “C’mon People,” “Lonely Road,” “Only Mama Knows,” “House of Wax,” “Hope of Deliverance” (which still shows up sometimes, mainly on Latin American dates) and “Fine Line.”

Are there other solo or Beatle favorites of yours that you’d like to hear McCartney perform in concert? Feel free to share them in the comments.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 28 Comments

The Day The Beatles Came to Town

What was it like when a town was invaded by Beatlemania? Here’s Bill King’s 1985 look at what happened in Atlanta on Aug. 18, 1965, 20 years earlier, when The Beatles played Atlanta Stadium. This article originally was published in Beatlefan #41, August 1985. Also included at the bottom is a 1994 Beatlefan report on a soundboard recording of the Atlanta show that had recently surfaced at that time.

The Beatles with Atlanta Mayor Ivan Allen in August 1965.

The Beatles with Atlanta Mayor Ivan Allen in August 1965.

The Fab Four’s 1965 Visit to Atlanta

Attending last year’s show by The Jacksons at Atlanta-Fulton County Stadium, Tony Taylor couldn’t help thinking back to another show he’d seen at that same venue.
It was Aug. 18, 1965. Twenty years ago. The day The Beatles came to town.

“There really was no comparison between the Michael Jackson concert and The Beatles at Atlanta Stadium,” maintains Taylor, who as a deejay for WQXI-AM (“Quixie in Dixie”) helped emcee The Beatles’ show.

“The Beatles concert at Atlanta Stadium sticks in my mind as perhaps the greatest event I ever witnessed,” he says. “The entire stadium bordered on hysteria. I can still see the faces of the girls, tears in their eyes, as they hung over the wall and the policemen tried to restrain them. I’ll never forget it.”

Unforgettable. Unbelievable. Words like that are used by members of the crowd of 34,000 who attended The Beatles’ only Atlanta performance.

Even those who weren’t screaming teenagers at the time recall The Beatles’ visit — which preceded the arrival in Atlanta of the Braves — as an epochal event in the emergence of Atlanta as a major city.

“The excitement was shared by the whole community,” says Taylor, now in advertising but at the time the 28-year-old midday man on Quixie, Atlanta’s dominant Top 40 station. “The city took on a different character. The reserved Southerner became a hysterical fan.”

As they’d done around the world, John Lennon, Paul McCartney, George Harrison and Ringo Starr sparked unprecedented media coverage, beginning weeks before the show date. As early as July, Atlanta Mayor Ivan Allen Jr. was quoted by The Atlanta Constitution as saying The Beatles’ visit to Atlanta was causing a stir comparable to the 1939 premiere of “Gone With the Wind” — and in Atlanta, that’s quite a stir.
“The Beatles were a big event, no question about it,” Allen says. “It was a landmark for Atlanta.”

“It was the only time we ever had as much publicity for a show as we thought we should have,” jokes 65-year-old Ralph Bridges, whose Famous Artists firm promoted The Beatles’ Atlanta Stadium concert. “It was fantastic.”

Bridges, who prior to that time had promoted only a handful of rock ‘n’ roll shows, had passed on bringing The Beatles to Atlanta during their 1964 tour because he wasn’t sure he could meet the $12,500 guarantee. A year later, the guarantee for the group was around $50,000. But by then, it was obvious The Beatles’ popularity wasn’t going to fade any time soon, so Bridges took the plunge.

A ticket stub from The Beatles' Atlanta Stadium concert.

A ticket stub from The Beatles’ Atlanta Stadium concert.

Tickets for the concert at the then virtually new stadium went on sale in May. Lower level seats were priced by Famous Artists at $5.50. Upper level seats (where binoculars were essential) cost $4.50. Response was good, with ticket requests coming from as far away as Guatemala and California. “I was impressed,” Bridges says, “because among the first orders were one from Mayor Allen and one from Bobby Jones [the golfing legend and civic leader], who was buying them for his grandchildren.”

“My 70-year-old mother prompted me,” recalls Mayor Allen, who was 54 at the time. “She insisted I take her to the stadium to hear The Beatles.”

A week before the concert, Famous Artists ran an ad in the papers saying: “Beware of Rumors! We are not sold out. Good tickets still available.” Actually, that meant 8,000 of the upper deck $4.50 seats were available. All the $5.50 tickets were long gone. Because of the size of the stadium, however, it was not a sell-out, with about 2,000 of the 36,000 tickets printed going unsold.

Security — keeping the overenthusiastic fans from harming The Beatles or themselves — was Bridges’ greatest concern. “Superintendent James Mosely of the police department was a big help,” the promoter recalls. “He went with us to the Shea Stadium show in New York. That really scared us to death, because it was within an inch of a full-scale riot. The fans kept coming over the centerfield fence and I thought, ‘Oh, no! How are we going to stop them if that happens in Atlanta?'”

Bridges hired 150 off-duty policemen for the Atlanta Stadium show and, he says, “we prepared a series of lines of defense. It was just like a full-scale battle plan.” Between the crowd and The Beatles would be a waist-high fence, a rolled-wire barricade, a ring of wooden sawhorses and a line of 50 police officers. Insurance for the event cost the promoter $1,900.

Meanwhile, the media coverage had shifted into high gear. WQXI, the “official” Beatles station in town, was featuring regular reports on the progress of their American tour. The “Quixie A-Go-Go” TV show featured The Beatles prominently, and the Saturday before the show, The Atlanta Journal had an interview with Quixie deejay Paul Drew, who’d traveled with the Fab Four and was to join the ’65 tour in New York and travel with it to Atlanta. In a nice bit of overstatement, a photo of Drew in a Beatles wig was captioned: “Paul Drew, The Fifth Beatle.”

A newspaper ad encouraging fans to take the bus to the concert.

A newspaper ad encouraging fans to take the bus to the concert.

Sunday’s paper was full of The Beatles, including tips for parents asking that they not drive directly to the stadium, but let their kids use the special “Beatle Bus” shuttles. There also was a short item noting that “The Beatles in Atlanta: Blight or Blessing?” was the subject of the Rev. Howard Pyle’s sermon that day at Faith Baptist Church.

Wednesday morning, the Constitution’s front page declared that “B Day” had arrived. The Beatles and their entourage of 40 landed at a remote corner of the airport — out of view of fans waiting at the terminal — around 2 p.m. that afternoon on a private Lockheed Electra. Three limousines transported them to the stadium, where they would spend the entirety of their stay in Atlanta.

Janet Caldwell, now a political researcher but then a 31-year-old assistant to Bridges, remembers with amusement that despite all of Famous Artists’ fevered preparations, The Beatles still caught them napping on one item. “Ringo decided to wash his hair,” she says, “and we had to send out, rush, rush, for a hair dryer.”

“My wife Cindy had her stand-up hair dryer brought over from the house,” Bridges says. “That was real unusual in those days. Boys generally didn’t use hair dryers.”

Atlanta caterer Frank Cloudt, who’d been hired to provide The Beatles’ dinner, found them lounging on army cots in one of the stadium dressing rooms that afternoon. Cloudt wanted to know if it was true, as he’d been told, that they wanted hamburgers for their meal. “They said, ‘Oh, no, not again,'” he recalls.

So that evening The Beatles dined on their choice of meats — pork loin, a leg of spring lamb and top sirloin — along with corn on the cob (they had asked Cloudt if he could provide “corn on a stick”), fresh pole beans, fresh fruit, a relish platter and freshly-baked apple pie. A full bar also was provided, though only one Beatle (Cloudt can’t remember which one) had just one drink.

A year later, Cloudt says, when Bridges staged another Beatles show in Memphis, “they told Ralph that the supper they’d had in Atlanta was the best meal they’d ever had anywhere on tour. They enjoyed it.” So much so that they used Cloudt’s magic marker to autograph their four china plates, which Cloudt now keeps in a bank vault. Lennon’s punful plate reads: “Thanks for a flat wear.”

Cloudt, 42 at the time, was not a fan of The Beatles’ music and had approached the assignment with mixed feelings. But after spending some time sitting with the group and talking to them, he says, “I was very impressed. They were well-mannered and easy to talk to. They just seemed like lonely young guys away from home. But they were very accommodating, posing for pictures with groups of VIPs who kept coming in to meet them.”

“They were very easy to get along with,” says Bridges. “Paul in particular. He was taking as many pictures of everyone else as they were of him.”

The obligatory Beatles press conference at the stadium — about 15 minutes of mainly nonsensical questions — began shortly after 5 p.m. Around 150 “reporters” were present, many of them from high school newspapers. There also were some members of the local chapter of the Beatles Fan Club, headed by 15-year-old Brenda Jean Bene (now known as “B.J.” and married to WQXI deejay J.J. Jackson), who’d come to present their idols with stuffed animals, rings, jellybeans and other presents.

“I remember they were very nice,” says B.J., who had met The Beatles the year before at the Gator Bowl in Jacksonville, thanks to arrangements made by her favorite deejay, Paul Drew. “They didn’t act like big hotdogs,” she says. “John was zany. George was sort of quiet and Ringo was, too. Paul was very gentlemanly and would really take the time to answer your questions.”

What followed that evening was splashed all over Thursday morning’s front page. Taylor introduced Mayor Allen, who took the stage to declare The Beatles “honorary Atlantans.” Then came the opening acts — King Curtis, the Discotheque Dancers, Cannibal and the Headhunters, Brenda Holloway and Sounds Incorporated.

Taylor, who stood next to The Beatles in the dugout as they waited their turn, recalls that “they looked tired, frightened. But when it came time to go onstage, that feat turned to a smile. It turned into a performance.” Caldwell, on the other hand, recalls, “They seemed to be enjoying the whole thing. They weren’t jaded yet.”

At 9:37 p.m., the crowd erupted into an ear-splitting shriek as The Beatles, clad in dark blue suits, ran from the third base dugout to the stage, situated on second base. “There seemed to be one continuous scream,” Caldwell says. “It was super high-pitched and unrelenting.”

“It was loud,” agrees B.J. “It was really hard to hear them over the screaming.”

The Beatles, however, praised the sound at the Atlanta concert as the best they’d encountered in America. (In those days, touring acts didn’t carry their own sound equipment.)

“I think what really impressed them was that they had enough monitors onstage so they could hear what they were playing,” says Duke Mewborn, president of Baker Audio, which provided the sound system for the show. The company, which generally does sound systems for places like Atlanta Airport rather than concerts, had installed the system for the stadium and so was asked to handle The Beatles’ show. “We gathered every piece of equipment we could beg or borrow,” Mewborn recalls. “We had two large clusters of loud speakers at first base and third base and about 5,000 watts of amplification. But we couldn’t anticipate how loud the crowd really was. It was awesome.”

Still, he says, “their management got in touch later and wanted us to do all their shows. That wasn’t our business, but we did consult on Candlestick Park and a couple of others.”

Inside the stadium, the sights were just as frenetic as the sound was loud. Caldwell remembers that “little girls would throw themselves bodily over the railings onto the rolls of wire and into the arms of the policemen, who would roll them back over.”

The six first-aid stations were kept busy, Bridges says, “mostly with cases of hysteria. I walked around the stadium to see what was going on, and the kids were just continually yelling. I asked a couple of them why they didn’t stop screaming so they could hear the music, and they said they just couldn’t help it.”

Bridges also remembers that, from the stage, the crowd “looked like thousands of fireflies because of all the cameras that were flashing all the time. I thought it was really beautiful.”

The show, covered with four pages of pictures and stories in the Constitution and six pages in the afternoon Atlanta Journal, began with “Twist and Shout.” Then came “She’s a Woman” (during which McCartney’s mike fell over), “I Feel Fine,” “Dizzy Miss Lizzie,” “Ticket to Ride,” “Everybody’s Trying to Be My Baby” (Harrison’s only lead vocal), “Can’t Buy Me Love,” “Baby’s in Black,” “I Wanna Be Your Man (Starr’s vocal), “A Hard Day’s Night,” “Help!” and “I’m Down.”

“It was a good show,” B.J. recalls. “Better than in Jacksonville. It was perfect weather, unlike Jacksonville, where the winds gave Ringo a hard time.”

Front page coverage in the next day's edition of The Atlanta Journal.

Front page coverage in the next day’s edition of The Atlanta Journal.

Press coverage of the concert generally was favorable, if a bit condescending. The Journal said that “hearing one of their concerts is the most amazing and entertaining headache a person can get.”

After the show, the limos took The Beatles directly back to Atlanta Airport, where they eluded a crowd of 200 fans and took off just before midnight for Houston, where their next show was scheduled for 3:30 p.m. the next day.

In articles that ran in the Atlanta papers over the next few days, it was revealed that McCartney had been the heaviest seller at the stadium concession stands, that the state had garnished $5,176 in state income taxes before the show (but expected to refund part of that), and that the show had grossed about $240,000.

“It was the biggest gross we ever had,” says Bridges, whose firm now is mostly a booking agency for acts like Ferrante & Teicher. “But when we got through figuring it up and paying everybody, I think we lost money. Still, we were glad we did it, because we got so much notoriety. It was the biggest thing that ever happened to us.”

And, it might be argued, the biggest thing ever to happen to Atlanta Stadium.

Beatles Atlanta Soundboard Recording Surfaces!

In the fall of 1994, a soundboard tape of The Beatles’ Atlanta Stadium concert surfaced. Here’s Bill King’s report, originally published in Beatlefan #91, November 1994. 

A previously uncirculated and (so far) unbootlegged soundboard recording of The Beatles’ Aug. 18, 1965, concert at Atlanta Stadium surfaced recently in Atlanta.

The tape — not to be confused with the bogus concert performance mistakenly passed off by bootleggers as Atlanta in the early ’70s – has slight stereo separation and features emcee Paul Drew’s pre-performance comments (mentioning his travels with The Beatles and plugging a couple of upcoming shows for the same promoter) and his band introduction. Drew, then the top deejay on WQXI (“Quixie in Dixie”), was the city’s “Fifth Beatle”.

The tape has 10 of the 12 songs done that night — “Twist and Shout,” “She’s a Woman,” “I Feel Fine,” “Ticket to Ride,” “Everybody’s Trying to Be My Baby,” “Can’t Buy Me Love,” “Baby’s in Black,” “I Wanna Be Your Man,” “Help!” and “I’m Down” — with “Dizzy Miss Lizzie” and “A Hard Day’s Night” missing.

The Beatles’ stage patter on the tape is notable because, while familiar, it includes a couple of comments not previously heard on tapes from the ’65 tour. After “She’s a Woman,” McCartney is addressing the crowd of 34,000 and comments on the sound. (The Beatles said Atlanta had the best sound of the tour because they actually could hear themselves.) “We’d like to carry on now — ooh! It’s loud, isn’t it? Hey? Great!” he says before returning to his introduction of “I Feel Fine.”

After that number, McCartney again thanks the crowd and in the midst of introducing the next number, he asks “Hey, can you all hear me? Can you hear me? [Audience screams] Great, marvelous!” and resumes the introduction with Lennon saying off-mike, “They can all hear, Paul.”

While introducing “Can’t Buy Me Love,” McCartney says: “This next song is one where if you all feel like clappin’ your hands, well, do so, in this one. I’ve been sayin’ this for about three days [the tour had begun Aug. 15 in New York at Shea Stadium] and nobody ever claps ’em, but don’t worry.”

Lennon inserts a Southern cliche into the next intro: “Thank you, folks. You all” and lapses into some of his gibberish before saying the next song is “a slow number and it’s also a waltz, and it’s called ‘Baby’s in Black . . . pool’” in a play on the name of a British resort town.

After “I Wanna Be Your Man,” Lennon kills time before the missing “A Hard Day’s Night,” laughingly saying: “We’ll have to wait a minute now while Paul changes his bass, he’s broken a string! Have you? Whaddya gonna do? Keep talking? What shall I say? [uses phony sincere voice] It’s simply wonderful to be here . . . I can’t think of anythin’ to say so why don’t you just hum and talk to yourselves for a bit.”

Then, after an audible tape splice, Lennon refers to the missing “A Hard Day’s Night” when he introduces “Help!” by saying, “this is also a song from a film we made, and it’s the last film we made.”

The origin of the soundboard recording has not been determined, but the comments and performances match another uncirculated tape in different hands that consists of the beginnings and endings of songs from the Atlanta performance. The two tapes differ in sound quality and slightly in contents: The excerpt tape contains a portion of the missing “Dizzy Miss Lizzie” but ends after “I Wanna Be Your Man.”

The story that accompanied the soundboard tape — that it was made for a reporter from one of the local papers covering the concert — is dismissed as improbable by those familiar with the show. Duke Mewborn of Baker Audio, who handled the sound for the show, said whoever made the tape had to have taken it from their feed. “I don’t remember anybody taping it but that’s not to say someone didn’t ask us for a feed and we gave it to ’em. I just don’t remember it,” he said.

The story surrounding the excerpts tape, which only has one channel of sound, is that it was made at the behest of a local radio station which wanted to use the bits in some sort of promotion.

As we went to press, word already was circulating that one of the underground labels in Italy, where copyright law still allows Beatles concert recordings to be issued legitimately, was planning to issue the soundboard recording of the Atlanta show, paired with the new improved Shea recording that has shown up on a couple of other bootlegs.

(Rick Glover and Glenn Neuwirth contributed to this report.)

Postscript: A speed-corrected and less-hissy bootleg of the tape, “The Beatles Live at Atlanta Stadium, Atlanta, GA 8/18/65” (Toby BBCD 0001), was issued early in 2005 as a limited edition. The version of the Atlanta soundboard recording available on YouTube includes “Dizzy Miss Lizzy” (spliced in from the excerpts tape) but is still missing “A Hard Day’s Night.”

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 4 Comments

Wandering Early and Late … With James Taylor

Beatlefan Contributing Editor Tom Frangione got to take part in a Sirius XM session with James Taylor on June 19 and talked with the star about what it was like to be on The Beatles’ Apple Records label early in his career. …

James Taylor and Tom Frangione

James Taylor and Tom Frangione

Rock and Roll Hall of Famer and former Apple Records recording artist James Taylor has hit the road with a vengeance to promote his superb new album “Before This World.” Capping off a week which saw his widely hailed appearance on the Jimmy Fallon “Tonight” show and a satellite concert broadcast from New York’s famed Apollo Theater, JT was on hand to do a Town Hall session for Sirius XM radio and a rare in-store signing appearance.

The Town Hall was part of Taylor’s monthlong celebration on Sirius XM, where he had a dedicated channel playing loads of familiar favorites, deep album tracks, demos and of course, the new album. Specialty programming included “Top 10” shows hosted by artists such as Sheryl Crow, and a simulcast of the Apollo concert. The Town Hall (similar to ones done by Billy Joel and others) was hosted by Bob Costas, a great choice given one of the new album tracks is “Angels Of Fenway,” chronicling the live struggles of Red Sox nation.

Lanyard for JT's Sirius XM apperaance.

Lanyard for JT’s Sirius XM apperaance.

The ever savvy Taylor was keenly aware of his surroundings, the hometown of the “evil empire” that is the New York Yankees. I didn’t have the heart to tell him I was a Mets fan; citizens of Red Sox nation still get a twitch when they hear that, harking back to the 1986 World Series.

Our baseball “bond” was strengthened by his regaling of the 2004 ALCS where the Sox rallied from a 3-0 deficit to take the series from the Yanks — in the Bronx, yet — a game I was lucky enough to attend (the sight of Yankee fans throwing garbage at their own as they came off the field is forever emblazoned in my memory, but I digress …)

About 30 fans were invited guests for the session, about 10 of whom, myself included, got to ask JT a question as part of the broadcast. Of course, I framed it within the context of the new album, whose opening cut “Today, Today, Today” is about establishing ones’ self, and planting a flag, and as JT recalled in the liner notes, took him back to his own 1968 journey to London. I asked him to share what it was like to record under The Beatles’ auspices, and come out of it knowing he “birthed” one of his mentors’ all-time greatest love songs, as his “Something in the Way She Moves” clearly made a mark on one George Harrison.

In the Sirius XM studio.

In the Sirius XM studio.

Taylor recalled his audition for Paul McCartney and Harrison at Apple being arranged by Peter Asher. Recording at Trident, concurrent with the Beatles own White Album sessions in the summer of 1968, was clear in his memory, as he cited certain sessions he attended (but didn’t play on), including those for both “Hey Jude” and “Revolution”.

As for “Something in the Way She Moves,” JT graced us with a little guitar demonstration to show how he copped The Beatles’ own “I Feel Fine” for the hook in his song’s chorus (“she’s been with me now for a long long time and I feel fine”).

"Number One" by Hoke Simpson.

“Number One” by Hoke Simpson.

Another highlight of the session was Costas asking JT about the first record he ever bought, which turned out to be “Number One” (no, not the Rutles number) by Hoke Simpson in honor of the 1957 North Carolina Tar Heels college basketball championship, which he had long ago lost track of. Sirius XM’s resident programmer extraordinaire Lou Simon, who handled the specialty channel for Taylor, knew of this in advance and managed to track down a copy (mint, yet!) to present and air during the broadcast, visibly a touching gesture for the sentimental Taylor.

Heading downtown after the broadcast, Taylor did a rare in-store signing at Barnes & Noble in Union Square, where there were about 500 eager fans in attendance. There was no Q&A or musical performance, but Taylor did take the time to chat with each fan he met. The store did a brisk business in sales of all five formats of the new release, as purchase of any and all would qualify for a bracelet granting admission to the event. He would sign one of each format (CD, CD/DVD, deluxe book edition, LP or “exclusive” clear vinyl). Ever on top of my JT-ness, I’d brought along a 6th edition, available through the Target chain, which contained three bonus tracks. He was gracious enough to sign that even if it was not a Barnes & Noble purchase.

Beatlefan contributor Nikki Denett (Tom's cousin) meets JT.

Beatlefan contributor Nikki Denett (Tom’s cousin) meets JT.

When I got to the signing table, he flashed a grin of recognition from our chat earlier in the day, and I broke the ice with, “Hey, where do I know you from?” and was sure to let him know how much his music has meant to me (things that would’ve been a bit out of place during the Q&A on the live broadcast), which he seemed very appreciative of.

I will forever treasure the inscription he took the time to write in the book of my deluxe edition: “for Tom, on a great day …. James Taylor (dated) 19 June ’15”.

Taylor and his All Star Band (where have I heard THAT moniker before?) are touring the US throughout the summer in support of the new album. Don’t miss it.

Tom Frangione

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

BEATLEFAN LETTERS: Viewpoints and Questions From Our Readers

Below are letters from some readers and the editors’ responses where necessary (in italics). Feel free to add your own comments below. And, if there’s something we’ve published, a topic in the Beatles world you’d like to sound off on, or you’d just like to ask a question, email BEATLEFAN LETTERS at goodypress@mindspring.com.

TO THE EDITORS:

Macca with Rihanna and Kanye West.

Macca with Rihanna and Kanye West.

I want to thank Bill King and Beatlefan for continuing to find ways to represent the millennial generation of Beatles fans (third-generation fans?) in the magazine. (I wonder how many of these fans might have been the youngsters contributing to the [Helter Skelter] department for children that the magazine ran back in the mid-1990s!) The Viewpoint in Issue #213 about Paul McCartney working with Kanye West and Rihanna written by Nikki Denett provides a nuanced assessment of a situation that, unfortunately, has tended to draw kneejerk, uninformed reactions from many older fans. And this isn’t the first time you’ve provided an outlet for the generation that is the children of the original Beatles fans. I remember your own son has written eloquently in your pages before, and you’ve had articles by the college student who is your office assistant [Brigid Choi]. Plus, as you’ve noted in your Publisher’s Notes, some of your regular contributors are second-generation fans who came of age during the Wings era or even afterward. Thank you for never viewing Beatles fandom as one bunch of likeminded folks who all grew up in the 1960s!

SANDRA CHARLESTON, email

(Thanks, Sandra. We love to have fans of all ages in our pages, and we urge anyone who’d like to write for us to contact us at goodypress@mindspring.com.)

Ringo likes to collaborate when writing songs.

Ringo likes to collaborate when writing songs.

I really enjoyed Ken Sharp’s conversation with Ringo in Beatlefan #213, especially the part that dealt with Ringo coming into his own as a songwriter. He said that while he’s written some songs on his own, “mainly it’s always a collaboration.” But he also says that he wrote “It Don’t Come Easy” and “Photograph,” and we know that although he was not credited, George Harrison played a large part in the writing of those songs. Don’t you think that after all these years it would be a great gesture on Ringo’s part to give co-writing credit to George?

TAD BROWN, Chicago

(Although it’s true George gave a very large assist to Ringo in the writing of those songs, we think if he had wanted credit, he would have taken it at the time. So, no, we don’t see a real need for Ringo to revisit the question of the songwriting credits.)

Beatlefan #209

Beatlefan #209

Hey guys and gals at Beatlefan, I’d like to thank you for really making an effort to mix it up over the past year in terms of who you feature on your front cover. As I write this, the past six issues have had a Beatles group shot (from “A Hard Day’s Night”), that lovely, wonderful “Venus and Mars” era picture of Paul, a vintage shot of George, Paul in concert, Ringo in concert, and this latest issue’s outstanding joint photo of Paul and Ringo together. Two or three of those probably rank among my all-time favorite Beatlefan covers, and I’ve been reading your mag since the mid-1980s! Keep up the great work!

DIANA RAMIREZ, email

(Thanks, Diana. It helps when new releases and reissues loosen up the supply of available shots. And we’d like to once again thank Ringo’s personal photographer, Rob Shanahan, and his publicist, Elizabeth Freund, for providing the shot used on the cover of #213 when we asked whether they had something showing Paul and Ringo together. We were very pleased and honored to run it on our front cover.)

A reader was upset that a Beatlefan writer preferred a McCartney album to one by Harrison.

A reader was upset that a Beatlefan writer preferred a McCartney album to one by Harrison.

I have held my tongue for several years concerning Howie Edelson’s obvious hate of George Harrison and devotion to Paul McCartney. As a journalist myself, I have cringed at the way Edelson puts nasty and ill-spirited digs at George into his news features or Q&As — comments that only belong in editorials or op/ed pieces. Now comes Issue 213 where he throws in that “Press to Play” is “a far better album” than “Cloud Nine.” THAT is a ridiculous comment that insults Harrison’s memory and all of George’s fans. (Yes, Howie, we exist!)  This is a disturbing trend in Edelson’s articles and I seriously question a Beatle publication so blatant in publishing such material. Look at the facts (1987-88 charts, articles of the time) and explain how Edelson comes up with his latest gem? I am a longtime subscriber to Beatlefan. But I am ready to cancel because of Howie Edelson’s irresponsible and unprofessional anti-Harrison rants.

TIM SMITH, Livonia, MI

First, a response from Publisher Bill King: Beatlefan is not a newspaper. It’s a journal of news and opinion, and we’ve always run opinions in our articles and even (gasp) in our news roundup, going back to the very beginning more than 36 years ago. I can’t speak to Howie’s preference for “Press to Play” over “Cloud Nine” (personally, I prefer “Cloud Nine”) but he has his own response below. In the meantime, I will say I think you’re cherrypicking his comments in claiming he is devoted to McCartney. You could fairly say Howie is devoted to Wings, but he’s been pretty brutal in some of his views on latterday McCartney. And, frankly, we think you’re overreacting here. Saying he prefers the McCartney album to the Harrison album is hardly an “irresponsible” and “unprofessional” rant that insults George’s memory or fans. It’s a simple statement of a fan preferring one album over another. If he’d compared “Press to Play” to a Lennon album, would you be as upset? Would you consider that an insult to Lennon’s memory and fans? We’d be sorry to lose you as a reader, but as you should know from reading our magazine we’ve always allowed our writers to express themselves freely on Beatle subjects, and we’re not about to stop now. Thanks for reading.

Howie Edelson responds:

Dear Tim,

Please see my loving tribute to 1982’s “Gone Troppo” (Issue. #192, Page 21). You are incorrect regarding what you perceive as my bias. My writing in said article proves as much. As a Harrison lover yourself, you might enjoy it.

All Glories Go To Sri Krishna.

See Yourself.

Love Comes To Everyone.

Howie 

 I really liked Howie Edelson’s interview with Mark Lewisohn! Howie said/asked so many of the things I would have. I finished the abridged version of Vol. 1 of Mark’s book and hands down it is the best, most complete, typo- and error-free, interesting book I’ve ever read about The Beatles! (and I have about 150 Beatles-related books!).

NANCY RILEY, email

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments